Navigation

Affinity Designer vs. Adobe Illustrator – Which One is Better for You?

Posted on by and

We all know that the standard graphics programs are the Adobe’s products. If you work in some visual field be its UI design, print design, illustration it is almost sure that you use or used some Adobe product.

Since we are working in the graphics field the Photoshop, Illustrator, InDesign group are the most popular and most professional application for our jobs. We know that to make this type of product not so easy, and your competition will be one of the biggest software development company in the world, but we still don’t understand the lack of the proper rivals. Of course, there are some open source ones like GIMP and Inkscape but – despite the fact that these are some serious programs – these are far away from the previously mentioned ones.

Nowadays we are a little bit luckier than in some years ago because today some determinative new software appear like Sketch and Affinity Designer. These apps make a great competition with the Adobe products and give us more alternative which is professional too.

In this article, we are going to look closer the viral Affinity Designer and make some compersion with Illustrator mainly to see what can this app make for us in our daily work. Is it good enough? Is it well supported? Let’s see it!

What is Affinity Designer

Shortly AF is a few years old vector-based graphics software which first was introduced to Mac, and in the last year, it was released on Windows.

It is a full-featured app for professional use. Well supported and costs only $49.99. Compared to this the AI is available for 25,39 €/month.

Previously we wrote an introduction article about Affinity Designer if you want to see a bigger picture check it out!

The Features

We should know that the Affinity Designer is a professional graphics app. Do not be fooled by its price. It is a high-quality well-supported application for a full range of graphical work.

It knows it rivals all main features and more. Of course, there is some difference, but this doesn’t mean that it knows less. There is some function which was done differently.

UI, How It Looks and Feels

We UI surface got the modern dark scheme (in the 1.6 version we get a light theme too). The panel structure is similar like in PS or AI, and this is not a surprise this standard was formed by mostly Adobe.

On the top part of the UI, you got the persona, the align and the pathfinder sections.

In this case, the persona means different, predefined workspaces. The first is purely vector based, in the second you can find the pixel tools, and in the third, you can locate the export tools.

On the left, you can find the tools. This section isn’t different from the tools you got used to in Illustrator. You can locate the selector arrows, curves gradient, different shapes and the typography tools.

In the middle, you can see the canvas area. You can use the default structure, or you can make more different artboards with the artboard-tool. The artboard-tool can be handy for UI design because you can quickly mock up the various viewports of your design.

On the right you can see the different panels like color, stroke, layers, transforms anything you used in your other drawing app.

There are just a few differences in the app’s UI compared to Illustrator this is useful for the end user because the switch is slight!

Import and Export

Okay, almost everybody uses an Adobe product. We have to open those source files we cannot exist without them! Fortunately, the developers at Serif thought about this. You can quickly open an Illustrator or Photoshop in Affinity Designer. There can be some quirks or inaccuracy, but you can get the necessary information.

The “Save for The Web” function is also available in Affinity named by “Export…”. Here you can export your files into the popular file formats, and you can also optimize them.

There is one more way to export your work namely the export persona. You can slice your projects and set the export parameters for each slice or the whole document. At Pathlove we ship our icons in three different PNG size and one SVG with one click.

Here we need to note that the AI SVG export functionality is way better than in the AD. In Affinity, there is some annoying behavior. There is some promise for the repair, but we don’t know more.

Support

With Adobe CC you get a lot of updates, bug fixes, and new features, this is expectable because CC has a monthly subscription model.

The Serif maintain a ~yearly release circle for the main updates and a more common one for the bug fixes. With the major patches, we got new features which feature mostly based on user’s requests. If you have any question or feature request go to the official forum!

Affinity Designer vs. Adobe Illustrator – Summary

The two application are real rivals. There aren’t any drastic difference, and both are great!

We think that this rival is good for us – the end users – because we get a better final product, but we also believe that there no need to choose a side.

In the coding program world, we already saw that there could exist a lot of great app like Sublime, VSCode, Atom, Brackets. These apps are similar, but each has its good and bad nature.

Choose that app which is best suited for you we can provide you that you won’t be disappointed!

4 responses to “Affinity Designer vs. Adobe Illustrator – Which One is Better for You?”

  1. Sorry es gibt erhebliche Nachteile! Ein ganz wesentliche Funktion fehlt bei Affinity, denn es fehlt
    nämlich das Objekt-Verlaufwerkzeug.Das ist höchst wichtig für plastische Darstellungen, auch
    Seim-Realnische Räumlichkeiten, Lichteinfälle usw. Natürlich kann Mann für den Preis nicht viel erwarten aber in einen Review – auch noch ein Produktvergleich darf keinem wesentlichen Vorteile und Nachteile fehlen.

    • Hi Joe!

      As you see this is an English site. It is not to nice to write here in a foreign language although I’ve tried to translate your comment. I’m still not 100% sure what are you saying.

      Of course, there are disadvantages too we mentioned the SVG export. This article shows the point from the Affinity perspective. Illustrator is the more notable app today there is no question. We tried to explain that this cheap (yep, this is a relevant section) can raise the competition. In one of our other article, you can find other disadvantages about Affinity Designer.

      I think your point can be valid too!

      Thank you for your comment!

      ps.: Unfortunately we will delete this message because in this form it is not too useful for most of us.

      • Hello Adam

        thanks a lot for replying. I am really sorry I wrote two Versions of my text, one in German and one in Englisch. Unfortunately, I confused the two and posted the wrong one to you. The German version was meant for a German Affinity Website.

        Sorry, but feel Affinity Designer has a very significant disadvantage over Illustrator and I do not mean on the output side of things.

        A very important feature is missing in Affinity – it lacks the Blend tool. This is very important for spatial, realistic and semi-realistic illustrations, light simulation, etc. Of course, one can not expect too much for the low-price and unbeatable value-for-money. However, a review–and especially–a product comparison should mention all significant advantages and disadvantages.

        • Hi Joe!

          Thank you for the English reply!

          Of course, it has some disadvantages but we find a lot of features which is way better here like elsewhere. Unfortunately, about the Blend Tool, we don’t know much so we can’t argue with that.

          About the low price. For ages, there was only one professional tool made by Adobe (we mostly think about Photoshop) and if you wanted to use another tool you get the answer: use GIMP. For this price tag, it is only available for professionals as it always was. We are really happy that there a high quality, rival app which is well developed.

          This is not about the price. These are really good programs. Everybody can use whatever he/she want. Unfortunately, the Affinity is not too current but it a massive userbase too.

          More disadvantages could have been in this article but this was written this way. In our previous articles, we mentioned more. We are sure in the future there will be a unique article just for the disadvantages (disadvantages for us).

          Thanks for your comment!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *